Oreopithecus was a bipedal ape after all: Evidence from the iliac cancellous architecture. Lovejoy and colleagues (1999) paper would likely have described these features as side effects of selection for a shorter pelvis with an anteriorly directed origin for the rectus femoris muscle. Harrison T. 1991. Abitbol MM. Together, they form the part of the pelvis called the pelvic girdle. But having played with that idea a little, I just don’t see much support for it in the skeletal remains. In bipedal walking, the pelvis is tilted on the coronal plane; that is, the hip joint opposite the weight-bearing limb drops (a condition known as "pelvic list") (Inman et al., 1981). 1971. 288-1. 2010. Adaptive radiation in the australopithecines and the origin of man. Science 326:70e1–70e7. Worse, as I discussed last fall, the model appears to have been derived from the a priori expectations about pelvis evolution that Lovejoy and colleagues published in 1999. (2010), the first time that Ardipithecus and Oreopithecus pelvic features have been compared (other than here on the blog): I think this comparison is very important. Response to Comment on the paleobiology and classification of Ardipithecus ramidus. This is not to say that the locomotor pattern was entirely monkey-like, but merely that the ancestral, generalized quadrupedal ancestor did not have great ape locomotor specializations, including rapid vertical climbing and long-armed quadrumanous movement (Lovejoy et al., 2009a). Ardipithecus ramidus and the paleobiology of early hominids. White and colleagues (2010) include this as their feature (iii), the “unique physis for the AIIS, shared only with phyletic hominids.” But this description seems exaggerated, when we consider what Lovejoy and colleagues (2009c:71e3) actually wrote: A “novel physis” refers to a separate growth plate for the anterior inferior iliac spine. Rook L, Bondioli L, Köhler M, Moyà-Solà S, Macchiarelli R. 1999. 2009b, 2009c). The grassy woodland habitat occupied by Ardipithecus would not have selected for the below-branch specializations of the forelimb and hand, and thereby would have given no reason for knuckle-walking as a terrestrial locomotor strategy. They propose that the ilia have flattened and extended in length independently in at least the three lineages of chimpanzees, gorillas, and orangutans (and we may add gibbons) as a consequence of sacralizing the lower lumbar vertebrae and reducing the flexibility of the lower back, thereby creating a short, stiff trunk. 60?81. The anterior pelvic tilt, along with other types of pelvic tilt problems, has an impact on the health of the spine and could be a direct result of a person’s inactivity or how a person sits. The top left image is indeed very close to the Ardipithecus model that Lovejoy and colleagues present in the current paper. This idea is far from new — before the early 1960’s, the human-chimpanzee clade was a minority viewpoint, and many scientists were looking for quadrupeds that might show that some of the “bipedal” features of our pelves were primitive instead of derived. I wish we had better than a cartoon model to compare. Morphological analysis of the mammalian postcranium: A developmental perspective. Anterior Pelvic Tilt (APT) is becoming more and more of an epidemic among both fit and sedentary individuals. Ardipithecus is a genus of an extinct hominine that lived during the Late Miocene and Early Pliocene epochs in the Afar Depression, Ethiopia. 1995. The other day, I started writing about the Sarmiento-White exchange on Ardipithecus, by describing how they disagree about the implications of the molecular clock. These adaptations mainly make sense in a canopy forest habitat, where there are tall trunks devoid of lower-story branches and a continuous canopy. One hypothesis would be the morphogenetic effects of selection for a shorter ilium length, the scenario published by Lovejoy and colleagues (1999). Lovejoy CO, Suwa G, Simpson SW, Matternes JH, White TD. Ardi’s long apelike ischia retain the long hamstrings lever arm necessary for powerful hindlimb extension in a flexed, quadrupedal position. However, many personal trainers are able to spot pelvic tilt from experience, since it can often be identified visually. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96:8795–8799. 2009b. Science 326:75–86. The upper right image is a simple superoinferior digital distortion of the chimpanzee without any reference to a known “end product” (Photoshop “scale function”). Sarmiento EE. The earliest species of this genus, Au. 1964. Conversely… the anterior pelvic tilt is the correct pelvic rotation for squatting [and] … The Ardipithecus pelvis at 4.4 mya was already more human- than chimpanzee-like. Australopithecus sediba is an extinct species of australopithecine recovered from Malapa Cave, Cradle of Humankind, South Africa.It is known from a partial juvenile skeleton, the holotype MH1, and a partial adult female skeleton, the paratype MH2. Consequently, bipedality in … It’s the exact opposite of perverse. Science 328:1105. doi:10.1126/science.1184148. These specializations are functionally associated with improving the stability at the hip joint when fully extended, and for increasing the mechanical advantage of the thigh flexors and knee extensors in upright postures (Harrison, 1991, 240).
. Lovejoy and colleagues 2009c report upper and lower bounds on acetabulum height for Ardi’s pelvis. Put those together with the elongation of the arms, reduction in the length of the lumbar column, and sacralization of lumbar vertebrae. I first stumbled across the pelvic tilt correction via JL Holdsworth’s Technique Series on elitefts. Careful climbing in the Miocene: The forelimbs of Ardipithecus ramidus and humans are primitive. p 235–244. The evolutionary history of menopause in humans has been one of the longest-standing areas of research interest in life history evolution. Posterior Pelvic Tilt (PPT) or "hip tilt" as it's often informally referred to is a common problem that affects many Americans. A forward tilt, called anterior pelvic tilt, may tighten up your low back muscles because it accentuates the small amount of naturally occurring curve that’s present in a healthy spine. You'll feel a gentle stretch of your low back. You see the problem of using a model instead of the actual fossil? The remainder of the skelton is in process. The femur and pelvis of Ardipithecus ramidus have characters indicative of both upright bipedal walking and movement in trees. Here’s the Oreopithecus paragraph from White et al. ramidus was more primitive than in later Australopithecus. Ardipithecus ramidus (ARA-VP-6/500), a hominin from 4.4 million years ago, exhibits synapomorphies with humans in … Lovejoy and colleagues (2009c, 2010) are just claiming there must have been one. Below the spine, and located just above the superior rim of the acetabulum, is a large, roughened triangular depression. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 94:11,747–11,750. It’s our job to approach models skeptically, to try to identify the implicit assumptions and bring them out to be examined. Ardipithecus, Australopithecus, and Homo can be thought of as the major phases of human evolution. Walking: This is quite an effective way to correct Pelvic Tilt. In respect of the preadaptive phase [viz., before hominins became habitual bipeds], it is of great significance that Oreopithecus had a somewhat shortened innominate with a relatively broad ilium (Schultz 1960). One aspect of the digital model got my attention more than the others, because it was not evident in the 1999 pelvis model. Anterior photographs of a chimpanzee pelvis (lower right) and that of A.L. At that time, these regions were joined as a single landmass, an island not connected to the European mainland, making it credible (though not certain) that Oreopithecus faced lower predation than mainland primates. 1964. Adaptive radiation in the australopithecines and the origin of man. In: Howell FC, Bourlire F, editors, African ecology and human evolution. Do 5 to 10 reps. Precisely the required changes required [sic] to bring about the changed function of gluteus maximus were thereore in progress in Oreopithecus and the early Pliocene horizon at which it occurred (Hrzeler 1958) would place it at about the right period in time. It requires the convergent evolution of a long suite of characters within all the living great apes in at least three separate evolutionary histories. Anterior Pelvic Tilt is the forward and downward tilting of the pelvis, and one of its major causes is prolonged sitting due to driving, working or inactivity. erectus. The os coxae are crushed, and the paper does not illustrate the parts in sufficient detail to for me to judge the reconstruction. In: Coppens Y, Senut B, editors, Origine(s) de la bipdie chez les hominids, Cahiers de Paloanthropologie. I’ve taken care to reference the description by Lovejoy and colleagues (2009c), the general discussion of Ardi’s locomotor anatomy in Lovejoy et al. The left os coxa is nearly complete but badly distorted, part of the right ilium is preserved along with a bit of the sacrum. These changes are a big help in our different ways of walking. If so, that functional role might well have occurred in Ardipithecus, another arboreal quadruped. Reconstruction of the sts 14 (Australopithecus africanus) pelvis. Lovejoy and colleagues (1999) emphasized this point – the pelvic features of hominins were likely to have evolved due to selection for a shorter pelvis, principally for biomechanical reasons, with other characters of the pelvis and femur changing entirely due to their genetic correlation with this major target of selection. As you exhale, engage your abdominal muscles, allowing that action to tilt your tailbone upward and close the space between your low back and the mat or floor. 1999) had the following, very long caption: Fig. Abitbol MM. Pelvic tilt 13,6° ± 6 bei Frauen und 13° ± 6 bei Män-nern. A study published in Manual Therapy found that up to 85% of males and up to 75% of females have an anterior pelvic tilt, even if they’re not experiencing symptoms. In their published reply to Sarmento, White and colleagues do not mention the long series of great ape postcranial features that they previously argued to be cases of parallel evolution (Lovejoy et al. If Ardipithecus was neither of these — and it wasn’t — then maybe it had an unexpected relation between these anatomical features. Originally described as one of the earliest ancestors of humans after they diverged from the chimpanzees, the relation of this genus to human ancestors and whether it is a hominin is now a matter of debate. Your pelvis helps you walk, run, and lift weight off the ground. To test the importance of facultative bipedality in Ardipithecus, I think we’ll have to have a better model for how quadrupedality functions in an ape pelvis that is nonetheless very different from those of living great apes, including orangutans. 3 and SI Appendix, Table S5). Here’s a comparison of 3D models: Ardi looks very obviously like the human and Lucy, and very different from the chimpanzee, right? Science 326:100–106. Lovejoy CO, Cohn MJ, White TD. Ardipithecus, Rook L, Bondioli L, Khler M, Moy-Sol S, Macchiarelli R. 1999. In (P. Dohlinow & V.M. The pelvis and femur of Ardipithecus ramidus: The emergence of upright walking. I have a major hesitation that keeps me from writing anything about the Ardipithecus pelvis beyond those descriptions: Independent investigators at present cannot verify or replicate any comparisons made in Lovejoy and colleagues’ analyses. Notably, a chimp pelvis is too tall to r… Research has found that those engaged most are two specific abdominal muscles: One is the multifidus, which extends and rotates the spine. Now, White and colleagues (2010) are forced to posit a fourth independent evolution of many of these traits in Oreopithecus. Can it be that orangutans, chimpanzees, gorillas, and Oreopithecus all acquired the distinctive “bi-iliac entrapment” of the lower lumbar vertebrae in four separate instances of evolutionary convergence? From the point of view of the pelvis, therefore, Oreopithecus is remarkably suitable as an Australopithecine ancestor in the stage before the adaptive shift to erect posture occurred (Robinson, 1964, 403).
Leave A Comment